top of page
Search

Diversity and Representation in Music Education: Are We Doing Enough?


Background of blue, red, orange, yellow, and grey paint strokes. In the center, text reads, "Diversity and Representation in Music Education: Are We Doing Enough?" By Amanda Grace Guilfoyle, EMBA, M.M. MUED

Music possesses the ability to transcend boundaries, evoke deep emotions, and weave captivating narratives that resonate with people from all walks of life. In the realm of music education in the United States, the selection and performance of pieces within middle and high school orchestra programs play a role in shaping students' musical journeys and perspectives on the world. However, a persistent issue within music pertains to its dearth of diversity and representation in repertoire choices: a matter that significantly impacts the inclusivity and cultural relevance of music education.


The core inquiry at hand is whether contemporary school orchestra programs adequately address diversity and representation through their selection of music pieces and curriculum. While orchestral music boasts a legacy steeped in tradition, it has faced criticism for its limited inclusion of diverse voices and perspectives.


Throughout history, traditional orchestral repertoire has overlooked the wealth of musical traditions from diverse cultures worldwide. The lack of diversity has consequences for music students as it restricts their exposure to a broad range of musical expressions. Also, it fails to represent the cultures and communities in which these students live. As music educators, it is our responsibility to critically analyze and address these concerns to ensure that our students receive an inclusive musical education.


By participating in this dialogue, we can strive towards creating an environment where every student can see themselves reflected in the music they study and perform irrespective of their backgrounds. This endeavor is not only about enriching experiences but also about fostering cultural understanding, empathy, and respect within our communities and beyond.


Skip to a section:


I. Historical Context


Orchestral music boasts a rich legacy spanning centuries with various styles and eras encompassed within its realm. However, the traditional repertoire of music has mainly been influenced by the compositions of composers hailing from cultural and historical backgrounds. This bias can be attributed to records that have focused on the achievements of straight, Caucasian men while neglecting the creations of women and individuals from BIPOC and LGBTQ+ communities. As a result, there exists a lack of diversity in the pieces commonly taught and performed in school orchestra programs.


For generations, Western classical music has held a position of privilege and dominance in the field of music. While this tradition has given birth to incredible and world-changing compositions, it has often marginalized the musical contributions made by individuals belonging to diverse cultural, ethnic, and racial backgrounds. Consequently, the repertoire taught in school orchestra programs fails to encompass the range of musical expression found worldwide.


The impact of this lack of diversity on music education is profound. Students who come from different backgrounds may find it challenging to establish a connection with a repertoire that fails to represent their heritage or musical traditions. This can result in feelings of alienation and disengagement from the music they are learning, ultimately impeding their growth and sense of belonging within the orchestra community. Furthermore, the standing issue of variety in orchestral repertoire has led to a continuous cycle of underrepresentation and restricted opportunities for composers and musicians from diverse backgrounds to gain recognition and appreciation in mainstream music education. This not only hinders students from experiencing a range of musical genres and styles but also contributes to a larger cultural narrative that undermines the significance of diverse musical traditions.


As music educators, we must acknowledge this context and its impact on the students we teach. By comprehending the origins behind the lack of diversity in music we can take steps, towards addressing these disparities and strive to create a representative music education environment that caters to all students.


II. The Current State of Diversity in School Music Programs


When examining the state of school orchestra programs, it's clear that the music we teach and perform still lacks diversity and representation. While there have been efforts to introduce pieces the traditional repertoire remains dominant. This raises questions about how inclusive and culturally relevant the music presented to students is.


Typically, school orchestra programs focus on original compositions and arrangements of compositions by known classical composers like Mozart, Beethoven, and Tchaikovsky. While these works are undoubtedly excellent and offer value, their continued emphasis perpetuates a lack of diversity in orchestral music education.


If we take the time to look at the music we have in our curricula, we can see that there is a small representation of composers from different backgrounds in school orchestra curricula. Composers who are women, LGBTQ+, and people of color are often underrepresented or ignored in the standard repertoire. This not only deprives students of encountering a range of musical voices but also reinforces a narrow view of what qualifies as orchestral music. While there is a large disparity in the music we play, it is worth mentioning that many composers who come from diverse populations, like Soon Hee Newbold, have been making a huge impact on the repertoire of middle and high school orchestra music. However, there is always room for improvement when it comes to embracing and celebrating diversity in school orchestra music. It only takes a moment to look at the majority of music in your cabinets at school and to see that we can do better.


Despite the challenges, there are inspiring examples of orchestra and music programs that have taken measures to prioritize diversity and representation in their curriculum. El Sistema and the Sphinx Organization are a few initiatives that have made huge impacts in this area. Many educators have embraced approaches to selecting repertoire by incorporating works from composers and drawing from a wider range of musical traditions. These efforts have shown how exposing students to a representative repertoire can have a positive impact on fostering cultural awareness and enhancing their musical experiences.


As we examine the landscape of school orchestra programs it becomes evident that there is an opportunity for a shift within the broader orchestra community. By reassessing and expanding the repertoire taught in school orchestra settings, educators can create culturally relevant musical experiences for their students. This will empower students to explore expressions develop an appreciation for global cultural heritage and gain a deeper understanding of music's role in society. Ultimately this will help them become empathetic individuals while nurturing a strong foundation in music.


III. The Impact on Students


The limited variety in the selection of music played by orchestras has an impact on students from underrepresented backgrounds. When students are mainly exposed to a range of composers and musical styles they may struggle to connect with their cultural heritage and musical identities. This lack of representation can lead to feelings of exclusion and disengagement potentially hindering students' overall growth as musicians and their sense of belonging within the orchestra community.


For students from ethnic and racial backgrounds, the absence of representation in the repertoire played by school orchestras can reinforce feelings of being marginalized. When their own musical traditions and cultural expressions are not acknowledged or celebrated in the environment in which they are playing music, students may perceive a disconnect between their lived experiences and the music they are taught. This can affect their motivation, self-esteem, and enthusiasm for participating in orchestra activities both within and outside school.


Additionally, when students are exposed to a diverse repertoire that represents different cultures, they have an opportunity to explore and appreciate music from various traditions. This exposure not only broadens their knowledge but also fosters inclusivity and cultural appreciation within the orchestra community. Students can have an enriching musical experience if they can relate to the music they perform. Research suggests that exposing students to a range of traditions can enhance their musical development, foster creativity, and promote cultural awareness and empathy. When students engage with music from all voices and perspectives, it helps them understand that music is a language that goes beyond cultural boundaries and that they can use music to connect with others and grow in ways they never could have before.


Recognizing the impact of diversity on students it becomes evident that inclusivity and representation in orchestral music education is crucial. Creating an environment where all students feel valued and empowered to explore their potential requires addressing the influence of repertoire selection on their experiences. Music educators should strive to build a supportive orchestra community that celebrates musical traditions making the educational journey more enriching for all students.


For exploration into the significance of providing a music education experience for students, I recommend reading "Initiate, Create, Activate; practical solutions, for making culturally diverse music education a reality" by Melissa Cain, Shari Lindblom, and Jennifer Walden.


IV. Challenges and Resistance


Promoting diversity and representation in music education comes with its share of challenges and resistance. Despite the growing recognition of inclusivity's significance in education, there are obstacles that educators and advocates encounter as they strive to bring about change in the classroom.


One of the hurdles lies in the rooted traditions and veneration surrounding classical orchestral music. Various stakeholders, including educators, administrators, and parents involved in music education may firmly believe in the value of the repertoire and the historical importance attributed to classical composers and may insist on educators only using those composers in their curricula. This reverence for tradition often leads to resistance when it comes to expanding the range of repertoire to include works by women, BIPOC, and LGBTQ+ composers.


Additionally, concerns may arise regarding how to incorporate musical traditions into orchestra programs. Some educators and administrators may feel ill-equipped when it comes to navigating styles or lack access to resources and support for integrating more diverse repertoire into their curriculum. Overcoming this challenge can prove difficult when striving for inclusive and representative music education practices.


Furthermore, there may be apprehension about pushback from students, parents, or the broader community when introducing new, diverse repertoire. Educators might worry about how people will react to changes in the curriculum fearing that these changes might be seen as a departure from established traditions. Resistance to change can also arise from issues such as the lack of representation of various voices in the music publishing industry limited performance opportunities and restricted professional networks. These systemic obstacles can hinder the visibility and accessibility of composers and their works making it more difficult for educators to incorporate repertoire into their programs.


To tackle these challenges and overcome resistance, a comprehensive approach is needed. This approach involves advocating for change, providing resources, and fostering a culture of collaboration. By promoting dialogue and offering development opportunities to educators we can break down barriers and create support for a more inclusive and representative orchestral music education approach.


V. Strategies for Improvement


To ensure that school orchestra programs embrace diversity and inclusivity, one effective strategy is to incorporate music from a range of cultural traditions into your school orchestra's repertoire, especially showcasing the rich culture of your own students and the wider community in which they live in. By doing this, music educators can provide students with a diverse and comprehensive musical experience enabling them to appreciate the rich tapestry of global musical expressions. It also allows them to connect with their culture and history in a meaningful way.


Furthermore, music educators can foster engagement with traditions by inviting guest musicians, conductors, or composers from diverse cultural backgrounds to collaborate with their students. This not only enhances the students' musical education but also promotes cultural exchange and understanding within the school community.


Community involvement is another aspect of promoting inclusivity in school orchestra programs. By establishing connections with local organizations, inviting guest artists for workshops and performances, and actively participating in community events, school music programs can create opportunities for students to engage with diverse musical traditions, whether they are part of that community or not. Through these experiences, students can develop an appreciation for a wide variety of cultures and traditions.


By incorporating these tactics and methods, music teachers can strive to develop orchestra programs that are more inclusive and diverse. This will enhance students' musical education and promote a fair and culturally dynamic learning environment, both within and beyond the confines of the orchestra room.


VI. Looking to the Future


By placing importance on embracing diversity and ensuring equal representation in school orchestra programs, educators have the power to lay the foundation for a fair and equitable future in the realm of classical and orchestral music. Embracing a variety of traditions and fostering an environment that appreciates cultures can lead to a more vibrant and enriched musical landscape, in middle or high school and beyond, into adulthood. Students who are exposed to a range of styles and cultural influences are better equipped to become well-rounded musicians with a deeper understanding of global traditions and cultures.


Moreover, prioritizing diversity in school orchestra programs has lasting effects that go beyond music education. It has the potential to contribute towards creating a kind, loving, creative, and equitable society by nurturing a generation of individuals who are not only skilled in music but also culturally aware and open-minded.


To bring about change and promote diversity in school orchestra programs educators, administrators, and the wider music education community must advocate for and implement inclusive practices. This may involve updating curriculum standards to encompass a range of traditions as well as providing professional development opportunities for educators to expand their knowledge base and repertoire.


Additionally, administrators and policymakers need to allocate resources and provide support, for initiatives that aim to diversify music education. To ensure that all students have access to a music education that reflects the diverse world we live in, educational institutions must prioritize funding for programs that promote inclusivity and representation. While we music educators may not have control over government funding and policies, we can still be advocates for our community. I implore you to urge your representatives to make decisions that benefit all students, not just those of the majority demographic.


Promoting diversity and representation in music requires open dialogue and collaboration among educators, administrators, musicians, and the broader community. By facilitating conversations about the importance of inclusivity in music education, we can work together to identify barriers to diversity and develop strategies to overcome them.


Additionally, by collaborating with organizations, community leaders, and musicians from various backgrounds we can gain valuable insights and resources to foster inclusivity in school orchestra programs. By building connections and forming partnerships, the music education community can create an environment that embraces students from all walks of life.


In conclusion, it is vital for the music education community to wholeheartedly support diversity and representation in school orchestra programs. By doing so, we can pave the way for a future where orchestral music thrives with cultural vibrancy and make the orchestra room a place where all voices, traditions, and experiences are heard and celebrated.

16 views0 comments
bottom of page